That Blows-Were you really over the limit??

Historical note: This article discusses breath-testing problems reported in Sarasota and Manatee counties in 2011. It does not describe the current condition of those machines or the status of those cases.

Prosecutors have decided not to use alcohol breath-test results in about 100 current DUI cases in Sarasota and Manatee counties after learning about problematic Intoxilyzer 8000 breath-test machines.

The 12th Circuit State Attorney’s Office reviewed DUI cases this week and will send letters notifying defendants who were tested on five Intoxilyzer 8000s that the machines were not working properly and therefore the breath-test results will not be used as evidence against them. “It doesn’t mean this is the end of those cases, just we’ll be prosecuting them without the breath tests,” said Assistant State Attorney Spencer Rasnake, supervisor of the division that prosecutes most DUI cases. But the lack of breath-test results could mean dropped charges and better plea deals for some drunk driving suspects.

The flawed breath-test results play a role in about one of every three pending DUI cases in Sarasota County, and just a handful of cases in Manatee County. For instance, the machine at Sarasota County’s South County jail in Venice had reported that some drivers blew 10, 11 or even 12 liters of breath into the machine. That improper sample size of breath volume can taint the results of the breath test, experts say.

The breath volume is important, ensuring that air comes from the deep part of the lungs, where blood and air interact inside the body. A machine that incorrectly reads one liter of breath as two liters could be testing a bad sample. And a machine that incorrectly reads two liters as one could contribute to the conclusion that the user had refused to blow sufficient volume, which can mean the loss of a driver’s license as if the test had been refused.

Breath-test results can be powerful evidence in a DUI trial. Under Florida Statute § 316.193, the State can prove DUI by showing that a person drove or was in actual physical control of a vehicle with a breath-alcohol level of 0.08 or more grams of alcohol per 210 liters of breath. Under § 316.1934, a qualifying result is also prima facie evidence of impairment, which the defense may contest. The machine’s reliability and the testing procedures therefore matter. Here, prosecutors decided not to use results from the affected machines; that does not establish that a court excluded every result.

However, a larger issue looms with respect to past convictions based on the results of the Intoxilyzer 8000 breath test in Sarasota and Manatee counties. The Florida Department of Law Enforcement has reported that they fixed the machines in July 2011, but inspectors never noted how far off the breath-volume calculations were, and there is no way to know how long the machines were working improperly. FDLE started quietly fixing the machines in January and putting them back into service. Sarasota County’s machines were fixed in July. These problems raise questions about convictions that relied on results from the affected machines. Whether a particular conviction rested on an unreliable test would require review of that defendant’s test results and the machine’s inspection and maintenance records.

What recourse might an individual convicted of DUI in Sarasota and Manatee have? The answer is shocking-FDLE officials have chosen to not inform defendants who may have been wrongfully convicted or unfairly lost their driver’s licenses after being tested on the flawed machines and then convicted.

Florida is no stranger to state owned and operated devices, remember the swinging chads? What recourse was there for those voters? Oh yeah-they got George W. Bush for four years.

By: David Edelstein October 17, 2011.on November 14, 2011.