Grand Theft Attorney in Miami, FL
If you have been charged with grand theft in Miami, your defense may turn on questions the prosecution must answer: what property was taken, who it belonged to, and how its value was determined. David Edelstein began defending people accused of grand theft as an assistant public defender in Miami-Dade County. He has continued to handle these cases for more than 25 years at his Miami criminal defense firm.
What Is Grand Theft in Florida?
Grand theft in Florida is generally a felony when the property allegedly stolen is worth $750 or more. Theft of property worth less than $750 is generally a misdemeanor, but exceptions apply based on the type of property, where it was taken, and prior theft convictions.
Say a laptop cost $1,200 new. By the time it was taken, it was several years old and had a cracked screen. Used laptops in that condition may sell for less than $750. For theft charges based on value, Florida law looks first to the market value at the time and place of the alleged theft. If that value cannot be established, the law allows the cost of replacing the property within a reasonable time after the offense.
If the property is worth $749.99, the charge is generally first-degree misdemeanor petit theft, carrying up to one year in jail, unless a statutory exception makes the offense a felony. Depending on the amount, shoplifting can also be classified as a felony or misdemeanor petit theft charge.
A receipt can show what the owner paid. Photos of the damage, repair records, and sales of comparable used laptops can help us test the value listed in the police report.
If the accusation involves taking money, inventory, or other property from your employer, see our employee theft defense page for issues specific to workplace cases.
Types of Grand Theft Charges in Miami
Most (but not all) types of cases involving grand theft in Miami are based on the value of the alleged stolen property. According to Florida Statute 812.014, there are three degrees:
- First Degree Grand Theft (The property value is $100,000 or more) Maximum Penalty: up to 30 years in state prison and a fine of up to $10,000 (First-Degree Felony)
- Second Degree Grand Theft (The property value is $20,000 or more but less than $100,000) Maximum Penalty: up to 15 years in state prison and a fine of up to $10,000 (Second-Degree Felony)
- Third Degree Grand Theft (The property value is less than $20,000, but $750 or more) Maximum Penalty: up to 5 years in state prison and a fine of up to $5,000 (Third-Degree Felony)
As explained above, although the value is usually what determines the degree, the actual property that was allegedly stolen can sometimes determine the degree of theft. For example, when a firearm or motor vehicle (“grand theft auto”) is allegedly stolen, the theft is classified as grand theft in the third degree—a third-degree felony. Also, the property type and its value can sometimes determine the degree of theft. Most of the time, though, the value alone controls the crime’s degree. A criminal defense attorney from our law firm can give you a free case evaluation of your theft charge and answer any further questions you may have about theft under Florida law.
When an accusation includes selling or pawning stolen items, prosecutors may also pursue a dealing in stolen property charge. The rules governing theft and dealing charges arising from the same scheme can affect which convictions are permitted.
What are the Defenses Against Grand Theft in Florida?
Besides the value issue discussed above, there are other defenses someone can raise when facing a grand theft charge. Among them are:
Good Faith Belief of Ownership
If the accused had a good-faith, even mistaken, belief that they owned the property or had a right to possess it, this can potentially negate the required criminal intent. For example, if you borrowed a friend’s bike with their permission and later found out it was stolen, you would have a valid defense.
Consent
What did the owner give you permission to do? Permission to borrow a car for the weekend, for example, does not authorize you to sell it. Under Florida law, theft can involve an unauthorized use or transfer even if you received the property lawfully. The State must prove that you acted knowingly and with the intent required for theft. Returning property late, by itself, does not establish that intent. Messages about the agreement, requests to return the property, and what you did afterward can help show what happened.
Equal Ownership Interest
If you and another person both have an ownership interest in the property, taking or selling it might not constitute theft. For example, one partner taking assets during a business dissolution could use this defense.
Voluntary Abandonment
If the original owner discarded the property, intending to relinquish all ownership rights to it, taking it likely does not qualify as theft. However, proving this may not be easy, depending on the circumstances.
Valueless Property
While unusual, if the stolen property truly has no or only negligible monetary value, then a theft charge may not apply, as there is no loss or damages.
Hiring a skilled criminal defense lawyer is essential to raise any potential defenses and fight the charges. A grand theft conviction carries severe penalties, so contesting the allegations is paramount. An attorney can carefully examine the evidence and weak points in the prosecution’s case.
If this is your first criminal charge, learn more about our defense for first-time offenders, including diversion programs and other possible ways to resolve a case.
Contact an Experienced Miami Grand Theft Attorney
If you have the charging document, bring it to the consultation. Receipts, appraisals, and messages about permission to use or return the property can help us assess what the prosecution can prove.
If you are not a U.S. citizen, discuss the immigration consequences of theft charges with your lawyer before deciding how to resolve your case.
CALL US NOW for a CONFIDENTIAL CONSULTATION at (305) 538-4545, or simply take a moment to fill out our confidential and secure intake form.* The additional details you provide will greatly assist us in responding to your inquiry.
*Due to the large number of people who contact us requesting our criminal defense lawyers’ assistance, it is strongly suggested that you take the time to provide us with specific details regarding your case by filling out our confidential and secure intake form. The additional details you provide will greatly assist us in responding to your inquiry promptly and appropriately.
ALWAYS INVESTIGATE A MIAMI-DADE COUNTY DEFENSE LAWYER’S QUALIFICATIONS AND EXPERIENCE BEFORE MAKING A DECISION ON HIRING AN ATTORNEY IN SOUTH FLORIDA
