David Edelstein’s work on both state and federal criminal cases has been featured in several media outlets. Journalists also frequently contact him for insight into criminal cases as an experienced state and federal defense lawyer.

Florida Chief Justice: Skip Work in Courts Until JuneDaily Business Review

‘Atirador merece morrer’? Questã   o sobre pena de morte causa revolta nos EUA, UOL

She was suspended after saying she was sexually assaulted at school. Her mom asks whyMiami Herald

Disbarred Coral Gables Attorney’s Testimony Gets Former Client Acquitted MidtrialDaily Business Review

Suspended Police Sergeant Speaks Out After Alleged Gas TheftNBC 6 (WTVJ)

Miami-Dade car-loving cop: Accusations of fuel theft are bogusMiami Herald

Miami man who won legal battle over ‘First 48’ footage pleads guilty to murderMiami Herald

Miami_officials mull whether to charge diplomat’s son as a juvenile or adultGlobal News

Diplomatic immunity won’t fly for Marc Wabafiyebazu, Canadian teen in Miami shootout caseCanadian Broadcasting Corp. (CBC News)

Canadian diplomat’s son killed in MiamiCTV News

Appeals court, citing ‘The First 48’ reality cop show footage, puts Miami murder case in doubt., Miami Herald

Credit Card Confusion Sends Man to Jail NBC 6 (WTVJ)

Miami police parts ways with popular “First 48” cable showMiami Herald

CSI: Miami Consultant David Edelstein Helps Professionals Caught Between a Rock and a Hard PlaceAttorney at Law Magazine

George Zimmerman not guilty in murder of Trayvon MartinMiami Herald

Why would George Zimmerman waive the ‘stand your ground’ defense? Criminal defense lawyer David Edelstein explains. CTV News

Criminal Defense Attorney David Edelstein says the release of sensitive evidence in the George Zimmerman case probably wasn’t intentional, but it was negligent. CTV News

Suspended Police Officer Charged With Impersonating a CopNBC 6 (WTVJ)

Lynn student charged with threat to kill, injure after Facebook post: ‘Columbine .  Palm Beach Post

Libre bajo fianza banquero acusado de fraude en MiamiEl Nuevo Herald

Miami-Dade: Hundreds pay for training in bogus jobsSun-Sentinel

Legal load probably less in Miami for Minnesota Vikings lineman Bryant McKinnie Viking likely to receive more leniency than in Twin CitiesSt. Paul Pioneer Press



Little bottle of pills and Florida’s tough drug sentencing law have imperiled Penny Spence’s hopes of becoming a nurse. Her case, critics say, illustrates why the law needs to be changed.

Late one night last January, the 33-year-old Pembroke Pines woman was driving home from her waitress job, exhausted from working all night and caring for her ailing mother all day.

She veered off the road and hit a tree. Though she wasn’t hurt, three Coral Springs police officers responded to the accident, including a SWAT team member. The SWAT officer spotted a pill bottle in her purse, reached into the car and seized it. It turned out to be filled with Percocet pills.

Spence told the police that she had gotten the pills from her mother but had no prescription for them. She was using the narcotic pills, she said, to self-treat a painful back condition. She had no prior criminal record, and officers did not suspect she was intoxicated or impaired in her driving.

But because she had 48 pills, which weighed 42 grams, Spence was charged with drug trafficking — even though Spence insisted the pills were for her personal use.

Under Florida’s mandatory minimum laws for drug offenses, trafficking charges are triggered by drug weight, without consideration of intent to distribute or prior record. If a person is arrested with more than 25 pounds of marijuana, more than 28 grams of cocaine or more than five Percocet pills — which typically consist of 99 percent Tylenol — law enforcement authorities may bring charges of drug trafficking rather than mere possession. Prosecutors have the discretion to charge up or down.

If convicted of drug trafficking, a defendant faces a mandatory sentence of at least three years in prison. The mandatory minimums rise for larger amounts. Those possessing 150 kilograms of cocaine or 30 kilograms of OxyContin or morphine — the equivalent of about 33,000 Percocet pills — are subject to a mandatory minimum of life.

Spence is facing 25 years — unless she accepts a deal offered by Broward County Assistant State Attorney A. Theodore Daus III. Under that deal, she would get two years of house arrest in exchange for a guilty plea. But then Spence would have a drug trafficking and felony record. That would kill her hope of becoming a nurse.

“This has completely transformed my life,” Spence said. “I feel the way the laws are written is too harsh for someone like me, a nonviolent first-time drug offender. That’s what drug court and drug treatment was set up for.”

The Washington, D.C.-based Families Against Mandatory Minimums said Spence’s case demonstrates what’s wrong with mandatory minimum drug laws across the country. The organization argues that such laws give prosecutors too much discretion and judges too little.

“I think the situation points out how a one-size-fits-all sentence doesn’t work,” said Laura Sager, the group’s national campaign director. “The punishment in this case simply does not fit the crime.” Sager contended that the prosecutor is overreaching, and the law doesn’t allow the judge to serve as a check on prosecutorial discretion.

But prosecutor Daus expressed amazement that anyone would criticize the house arrest deal he offered Spence — something not all narcotics defendants receive.

“If I had said, ‘She’s getting 25 years in prison, there’s no deal,’ you’d have a good story,’ ” Daus said. “But I think I made her a fair deal. She would have no prison time. It shows the system does work. I think [FAMM] should be giving me an award.”

Spence, he said, “just wants to have her cake and eat it too.”

Sager disagreed. “This charge will follow P