Marsy’s Law: Crime Victim Rights in Florida
Florida’s Marsy’s Law protects crime victims through Article I, Section 16 of the Florida Constitution. Voters approved the amendment in 2018. Named after Marsalee “Marsy” Nicholas, it expanded victims’ rights and provided express ways to enforce them.
If you or someone you love has been the victim of a crime in Florida, understanding these rights is the first step toward ensuring you are treated fairly and that your voice is heard throughout the legal process.
Why Was Marsy’s Law Created?
Marsy’s Law is named after Marsalee “Marsy” Nicholas, a California woman who was stalked and killed by her ex-boyfriend in 1983. Just one week after her death, Marsy’s mother and brother, Henry Nicholas, walked into a grocery store where they were confronted by the accused murderer. The family was unaware that the ex-boyfriend had been released on bail. This further traumatized Marsy’s family.
To honor his sister, Dr. Henry Nicholas later campaigned for stronger protections, rights, and notifications for victims of crime. Marsy’s Law was first passed in California in 2008. Since then, several other states have adopted versions of Marsy’s Law as constitutional amendments to expand victims’ rights. Florida voters overwhelmingly approved Marsy’s Law in November 2018.
Who Qualifies as a Crime Victim Under Florida Law?
Marsy’s Law covers a person who suffers physical, psychological, or financial harm, including threatened harm, from a crime or attempted crime. It also covers a person against whom a crime is committed. These protections apply to juvenile delinquent acts as well.
The definition includes a victim’s lawful representative, the parent or guardian of a minor victim, and the next of kin of a homicide victim, unless their interests actually or potentially conflict with the victim’s interests. The accused is excluded.
What Rights Does Florida’s Marsy’s Law Provide?
Marsy’s Law provides the rights listed below. Some apply automatically. Others, including notice of proceedings, attendance, the opportunity to be heard, consultation with prosecutors, and updates about the offender’s status, must be requested.
- The right to be treated with fairness and respect: Victims must be treated with dignity and compassion by law enforcement, prosecutors, judges, and other authorities. Their privacy should be protected when possible.
- The right to protection from the accused: Victims have the right to reasonable protection within the judicial process. Courts can impose no-contact orders and other restrictions. The safety and welfare of victims and their families must be considered when judges set bail and conditions of pretrial release.
- The right to be informed and present: Victims have the right to be notified of court proceedings, the status of the case, any plea agreements, and parole hearings. They also have the right to be present and heard at important criminal justice hearings — even if the victim will be called as a witness.
- The right to consultation with prosecution: Victims have the right to talk with prosecutors about their wishes, including requests for restitution. Prosecutors should consider the victim’s viewpoint as they build their case.
- The expanded right to make statements in court: Victims have the opportunity to submit verbal or written impact statements detailing how the crime affected their lives. This can influence sentencing outcomes.
- The right to privacy: Victims can prevent disclosure of information that could be used to locate or harass them or their families, as well as confidential or privileged victim information. This does not create a blanket right to anonymity. The Florida Supreme Court held in City of Tallahassee v. Florida Police Benevolent Association that Marsy’s Law itself does not allow victims to keep their names from the public. Separate laws may protect a victim’s identity in certain cases.
- The right to restitution: Victims have the right to full and timely restitution from each convicted offender for all losses suffered — both directly and indirectly — as a result of the criminal conduct.
- The right to proceedings free from unreasonable delay: Victims have the right to a prompt and final conclusion of the case, including any related post-judgment proceedings.
- The right to be informed of the offender’s status: Victims have the right to be notified of the conviction, sentence, place and time of incarceration, any scheduled release date, and the release or escape of the offender from custody.
How Marsy’s Law Strengthened Crime Victim Rights in Florida
Florida recognized victims’ rights in its Constitution before voters approved Marsy’s Law in 2018. The amendment expanded those protections and expressly allowed victims, their retained attorneys, lawful representatives, and prosecutors acting at a victim’s request to seek enforcement.
Victims may assert their rights before a trial or appellate court, or another authority with jurisdiction over the case. That court or authority must act promptly and state its reasons on the record. These protections are self-executing, meaning they do not depend on further legislation to take effect.
The Role of a Crime Victim Advocate and Attorney
Having rights on paper and actually exercising them are two very different things. The criminal justice process can be overwhelming and confusing for crime victims, especially when navigating it for the first time. That is where a crime victim advocate or crime victim attorney becomes essential.
Marsy’s Law explicitly provides that crime victims can seek the advice of an attorney with respect to their rights. A crime victim lawyer can help you request notice of proceedings, advocate for no-contact orders and protective measures, consult with the prosecution on your behalf regarding plea negotiations and restitution, and file petitions with the court — including appellate courts — if your rights are being ignored.
A crime victim attorney can also help you prepare and deliver a victim impact statement, request the redaction of legally protected information from public records, and pursue full restitution for your losses. In cases involving domestic violence, stalking, or sexual offenses, having a dedicated advocate by your side can make the difference between feeling sidelined by the system and having a meaningful voice in the outcome of your case.
Beyond legal representation, a crime victim advocate can connect you with local resources including counseling, shelter, financial assistance through Florida’s victim compensation program, and other support services to help you through the aftermath of a crime.
Crime Victim Rights in Miami-Dade County
The Miami-Dade State Attorney’s Office provides victim assistance services to help victims understand the court process, take part in their cases, and find support. These services complement a victim’s right to retain an attorney to assert and enforce their rights.
Victims must be given information about their constitutional rights in a card or another form that effectively explains those rights. This includes notice that they may seek legal advice about their rights.
Victims can ask that legally protected information be withheld from public records. Whether information in a court filing can be kept confidential depends on the applicable law and court rules; a request alone does not make every identifying detail confidential.
At the Eleventh Judicial Circuit, victim rights come into play from the very first appearance hearing. Judges are required to consider victim safety when setting bail and conditions of release. If you have retained your own crime victim attorney, that attorney can appear at bond hearings, plea conferences, and sentencing hearings to advocate on your behalf.
Upon request, you have the right to timely, accurate, and reasonable notice of public proceedings involving the crime, to attend those proceedings, and to confer with the prosecutor about a proposed plea agreement. For a first appearance, the applicable notice, participation, and consultation rights are satisfied by a reasonable attempt by the appropriate agency to notify you and convey your views to the court.
If you are a crime victim in Miami and are unsure how to exercise your rights, an experienced attorney can guide you through the process and ensure your voice is heard.
How to Assert Your Rights as a Crime Victim in Florida
Understanding your rights is crucial, but exercising them effectively requires knowing what steps to take. Here is what you can do as a crime victim in Florida:
- Request notification: Contact the State Attorney’s Office handling your case and request to be notified of all proceedings, including hearings, plea offers, sentencing, and any release or escape of the offender.
- Request a no-contact order: Ask the prosecutor to request, or ask the court to enter, a no-contact order prohibiting the accused from contacting you, your family, or coming near your home or workplace.
- Protect your privacy: Identify the information you want protected and ask your attorney or the agency holding the records which protections apply. Court records may require a filing under the rules governing confidential information.
- Prepare a victim impact statement: You have the right to submit a verbal or written statement to the court describing how the crime has affected your life — physically, emotionally, and financially. This can be presented at sentencing and can influence the outcome.
- Seek restitution: Give the prosecutor records of your losses, such as medical bills, lost income, property damage, and counseling costs, so the court can consider a supported restitution request.
- Hire your own attorney: You have the constitutional right to retain a crime victim attorney to represent your interests in the criminal case. Your attorney can appear in court, confer with the prosecution, and petition the court if your rights are being violated.
- File for enforcement: If your rights under Marsy’s Law are not being honored, you, your attorney, your lawful representative, or the State Attorney’s Office acting at your request may seek enforcement before a trial or appellate court, or another authority with jurisdiction over the case. The court or authority must act promptly.
Getting the Legal Support You Deserve
Marsy’s Law empowers crime victims in the legal process, but navigating the system on your own can be difficult. Our firm is well-versed in the nuances of Marsy’s Law and committed to protecting your rights throughout your case. We will:
- Advise you of your rights under Marsy’s Law and help you understand how they apply to your specific situation.
- Advocate for your full participation in the legal process — from the initial bond hearing through sentencing.
- Assist you in seeking appropriate remedies and full restitution for your losses.
- Help you prepare a compelling victim impact statement.
- Seek appropriate redaction or protection of information that the law allows you to keep confidential.
- Provide unwavering support and guidance every step of the way.
Don’t hesitate to reach out to our firm if you need strong advocacy to protect your rights as a crime victim in Miami.
Frequently Asked Questions About Marsy’s Law in Florida
What rights do crime victims have in Florida?
Under Marsy’s Law, crime victims in Florida have constitutional rights to fair treatment, reasonable protection within the judicial process, privacy as provided by law, full and timely restitution, and proceedings free from unreasonable delay. Upon request, victims also have rights to notice of public proceedings, attendance, consultation with prosecutors, and the opportunity to be heard at specified proceedings, including sentencing.
Can a crime victim hire their own attorney in Florida?
Yes. Marsy’s Law explicitly provides that crime victims can retain their own attorney to assert and enforce their rights. A crime victim attorney can appear in court at hearings ranging from the initial bond hearing through trial, plea, and sentencing. The victim’s attorney can also petition appellate courts if the victim’s rights are being violated.
Does Marsy’s Law apply to juvenile cases in Florida?
Yes. Marsy’s Law applies throughout criminal and juvenile justice proceedings. Victims of juvenile delinquent acts have the same constitutional victims’ rights as victims of crimes committed by adults.
What happens if my rights as a crime victim are violated?
Marsy’s Law is self-executing, meaning it does not require additional legislation to be enforceable. If your rights are being violated, you, your attorney, your lawful representative, or the State Attorney’s Office acting at your request may seek enforcement before a trial or appellate court, or another authority with jurisdiction over the case. The court or authority must act promptly on the request.
How do I assert my rights as a crime victim in Miami?
If you are a crime victim in Miami-Dade County, you can contact the Miami-Dade State Attorney’s Victim Services division for assistance with notification and advocacy. You can also consult with an experienced crime victim attorney to ensure your interests are fully represented at every stage of the criminal process.
What is a crime victim advocate?
A crime victim advocate is a person — either an attorney or a trained professional — who helps victims of crime navigate the criminal justice system. A victim advocate can help you understand your rights, connect you with resources like counseling and financial assistance, accompany you to court proceedings, and ensure that the system treats you with the fairness and respect you are entitled to under Marsy’s Law.
Does Marsy’s Law apply to domestic violence cases?
Absolutely. Marsy’s Law applies to victims of all crimes in Florida, including domestic violence. Victims of domestic violence have the right to be protected from the accused through no-contact orders, to have their safety considered at bond hearings, and to exercise all other rights guaranteed by the amendment. Victims can also seek injunctions for protection in addition to the protections provided by Marsy’s Law.
CALL US NOW for a CONFIDENTIAL INITIAL CONSULTATION at (305) 538-4545, or take a moment to fill out our confidential and secure intake form.* The additional details you provide will greatly assist us in responding to your inquiry.
*Due to the large number of people who contact our law office requesting our assistance, it is strongly suggested that you take the time to provide us with specific details regarding your case by filling out our confidential and secure intake form. The additional details you provide will greatly assist us in responding to your inquiry promptly and appropriately.
THERE ARE THOUSANDS OF LAW FIRMS AND ATTORNEYS IN SOUTH FLORIDA. ALWAYS INVESTIGATE A LAWYER’S QUALIFICATIONS AND EXPERIENCE BEFORE MAKING A DECISION ON HIRING A CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY FOR YOUR MIAMI-DADE COUNTY CASE.
