David Edelstein is an AV® Peer Review Rated criminal defense attorney
representing clients in state and federal criminal matters across the State of Florida.

If you or someone you love is facing criminal charges, you need someone on your side. 100% Criminal Defense 24/7

Sticks and Stones May Break My Bones but Words…

January 26th, 2012

There’s something special about being a cop.

Not only do you get to carry a badge and gun  and put people in jail.  You also get the special power to keep them there.  How, you ask?  Simple.  Just  open your mouth and say whatever you feel like saying.

In other words: you get the power to lie with impunity.

Most of the time, police fabrication and perjury slips under the radar.  From time to time though, it’s exposed and the public recoils in horror as prosecutors and police departments scramble to paint the perpetrators as rogue cops.

But the fact remains: even when they’re caught, these “rogue” cops often escape with little more than a slap on the wrist–if that.

Take the sordid case of Detective Ed Hill of the North Miami Beach Police Department. Mr. Hill escaped forgery charges Tuesday by agreeing to resign and give up his law enforcement accreditation.  As if the forgery allegation–that he faked a homicide suspect’s signature on a Miranda rights waiver form–isn’t bad enough, Mr. Hill–the lead investigator in the murder case against David Superville–was previously accused of having a romantic affair with the suspect’s wife.  Yes, you read that correctly.  Mr. Hill started dating the suspect’s wife after he safely booked him into the Dade County Jail.

Ed Hill and suspect's wife

Det. Ed Hill with suspect's wife

But ultimately, it was the  forgery allegation that led to  Mr. Hill’s “early retirement.”

So why didn’t the State Attorney’s Office file forgery charges against Hill?  The State Attorney’s final memo conceded that the form was a fake, but claimed that prosecutors wouldn’t be able to prove who did it: “ln order to prove a criminal charge of forgery, the state would have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the subject was the person who did the tracing.”  But, doesn’t the State always have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed the crime?  This seems to suggest that in order to file charges against Mr. Hill they needed to have a video of him, in flagrante delicto, pulling out his …. pen.

But the fact is, the State Attorney’s Office files and prosecutes hundreds if not thousands of cases a year without this type of evidence.   Without the video.  Without the body.  Without the “smoking gun.”

They’re called circumstantial cases–and this one’s a no-brainer.

Ask yourself, who had the means, motive, and opportunity to commit this forgery?

The State Attorney’s close-out memo points out that “there were multiple people who had access to the file and the documents” making it sound like anyone could be to blame for the forgery.  But it couldn’t have been just anyone.  It had to be someone who had access to the file.  And the only people who had access to the file work for the North Miami Beach Police Department.  And:

-Mr. Hill was the lead detective in the case.

-Mr. Hill had unfettered access to the file

-Mr. Hill was already in hot water for committing adultery with the suspect’s wife.

-It was Mr. Hill  who produced the document for the first time just as the case was going to trial  — four years after the suspect’s arrest.

Means, motive, and opportunity.  It doesn’t get any clearer than this.

So why then didn’t the State Attorney file charges against Mr. Hill?   Because this wasn’t Hill’s only case. And his credibility as a witness in other cases will continue to be an issue as it is in the  murder case against Lazaro Cortes–the alleged lookout in the May 2006 slaying of a North Miami Beach dollar store clerk.

In that case, defense lawyer Sydney Smith is arguing that his client’s statements should be suppressed because Hill coerced his client into giving a false confession.  He filed a motion on Tuesday citing the Superville case.

When asked about the State Attorney’s decision not to file charges against Hill, Smith observed: “If they prosecute [Hill], he’s of no value to them as a witness.”

And “therein lies the rub.”

4 Responses to “Sticks and Stones May Break My Bones but Words…”

  1. nicely written. Superville’s attorney did a nice job also.

  2. Great article. A nice reminder that the most dangerous place for a criminal to be, is behind a badge.

  3. I have heard of so many people who have been erroneously accused by policemen and coerced into giving false confessions that it really doesn’t surprise me. It’s a shame that the ones we have to be afraid of are the ones that are supposed to protect us….

  4. With great powers come great responsibilities….unfortunately, a lot of people can’t handle the responsibilities. They are…human. I.e. not perfect. I think the system needs an overhaul.

Leave a Reply