The Impact of Electronic Evidence on Criminal Defense

Technology has dramatically changed how criminal cases are investigated and defended in recent years. One of the most significant changes brought on by electronic evidence is the amount of data now available to law enforcement and defendants. In the past, evidence was limited to physical items that could be collected at the crime scene or through witness statements. Today, however, electronic devices like smartphones, laptops, and even smart home devices can provide vast amounts of data that can be used as evidence in court by both the prosecution and defense. This includes everything from text messages, videos, call logs, cell tower location data, GPS data, and social media posts. Electronic evidence has become a crucial component in the legal process, requiring criminal defense attorneys to stay up-to-date on the latest developments in digital forensics.

The Rise of Video Evidence in Criminal Cases

The widespread use of surveillance cameras and smartphones, along with the adoption of bodyworn cameras by police departments, has made video evidence available in most criminal cases. Video footage can provide a wealth of information and evidence that can be used in court, and it has become a key aspect in many criminal investigations. For example, surveillance camera footage can provide an unbiased account of events and can be used to establish the presence of a suspect at a crime scene or to refute an alibi. Similarly, smartphone videos and bodyworn camera footage can capture events as they unfold, providing invaluable evidence to either support or conflict with the prosecution’s case.

However, using video footage in criminal cases also presents challenges for criminal defense attorneys. The authenticity of the footage must be established, and the conditions under which it was recorded must be taken into consideration. In some cases, video footage may be manipulated or edited, and it is the criminal defense attorney’s responsibility to authenticate or challenge the evidence’s reliability.

The Growing Importance of Email, Social Media, and Messaging Apps

Electronic communications, such as emails, social media interactions, and messages exchanged via various apps, are increasingly becoming critical sources of evidence in criminal cases. They can provide an abundance of information about an individual’s activities, relationships, and communications, and they are often used by law enforcement to build a case or to establish a motive. For example, email communications can provide evidence of criminal activity or intent, such as emails discussing illegal drug transactions or plans to commit fraud. Social media and messaging apps can also provide similar evidence and information about an individual’s relationships, movements, and activities. Defense attorneys must navigate concerns surrounding the reliability and veracity of these communications to present and challenge this evidence in court effectively.

Mobile Phone Location Data

Mobile phone location data has also become a significant source of electronic evidence in criminal cases. The GPS technology in modern smartphones and cell phone triangulation data (data from multiple cell towers to determine a phone’s location)  allows for the collection of data that can be used to track an individual’s movements and location, and this data can be used by law enforcement to place a suspect at the scene of a crime. Mobile phone location data can also be used to track an individual’s movements leading up to and after a crime, providing evidence of their presence at the scene. This data can also be used to refute an alibi or establish a behavior pattern.

Location data from mobile phones has proven to be an invaluable resource in criminal cases. However, defense attorneys must address issues concerning the reliability and trustworthiness of such data when challenging and presenting this type of evidence.

Contact Us

The proliferation of technology has significantly changed the investigation and defense of criminal cases.  Historically, a criminal defense attorney’s primary focus was often on witness testimony and physical evidence. Today, however, electronic evidence plays a crucial role in many cases, and criminal defense attorneys must have a deep understanding of the technology involved to defend their clients effectively.

CALL US NOW for a CONFIDENTIAL INITIAL CONSULTATION at (305) 538-4545,  or take a moment to fill out our confidential and secure intake form.* The additional details you provide will greatly assist us in responding to your inquiry.


*Due to the large number of people who contact our law office requesting our assistance, it is strongly suggested that you take the time to provide us with specific details regarding your case by filling out our confidential and secure intake form. The additional details you provide will greatly assist us in responding to your inquiry promptly and appropriately.