Miami Wire and Mail Fraud Defense Lawyer

A federal agent asks about an invoice, or a grand jury subpoena calls for your company’s emails. Before agreeing to an interview, find out what the agent wants to discuss. If you received a subpoena, start with the records it calls for and the deadline for responding.

We defend people facing federal wire and mail fraud investigations and charges in Miami. An early question is what you knew when you made the statement investigators are asking about. An email from your supplier the day before you quoted a delivery date may tell us more about that than a complaint made months later.

An Interview Request or Subpoena

Ask the agent’s name, agency, and how to reach them. A voluntary interview and a subpoena call for different responses. You can speak with counsel before agreeing to an interview. For a subpoena, keep the document and envelope, note the return date, and get advice promptly about its scope.

Preserve original emails, attachments, texts, and accounting records. Leave timestamps and earlier drafts intact. If your employer has counsel, first find out whom that lawyer represents.

What the Records Showed at the Time

Suppose a vendor promised delivery by June and missed the deadline. A later complaint tells us the buyer was unhappy. The more useful records may be the supplier’s estimates, the vendor’s orders, and the messages sent before the buyer paid. Those records can help distinguish a missed commitment from a promise the speaker knew was false.

We identify who wrote or approved the statement, who saw it, what decision it could have affected, and which mailing or wire transmission allegedly furthered the scheme. A person who forwarded an email may have known far less than the person who negotiated the deal.

If prosecutors claim a loss, we compare the amount paid with the work performed, goods delivered, refunds, and the conduct attributed to you. The loss figure can matter at sentencing even though a completed financial loss is not required to prove the offense.

What Prosecutors Must Prove

Wire fraud and mail fraud are federal crimes involving fraudulent schemes carried out through wire communications or the mail. Wire fraud requires an interstate or foreign wire transmission. Mail fraud covers use of the U.S. Postal Service or a private or commercial interstate carrier; the particular mailing does not have to cross state lines.

Florida’s organized fraud statute addresses related conduct, but its elements differ from those of federal mail and wire fraud.

In a mail or wire fraud prosecution involving money or property, the government generally must prove the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

  • You knowingly devised or participated in a scheme to defraud someone by using false or fraudulent pretenses, representations, or promises;
  • the false pretenses, representations, or promises were about a material fact;
  • you acted with the intent to defraud; and
  • You used or caused the use of an interstate or foreign wire communication, the U.S. mail, or a private or commercial interstate carrier to help carry out the scheme, depending on the charge.

Scheme to defraud

The government must identify the money or property it says the scheme sought and what deception it claims was material. Related allegations can arise in healthcare billing, mortgage applications, or transactions involving credit cards or insurance claims.

On a false-invoice allegation, our employee theft page addresses related charges. The PPP loan fraud page covers allegations about loan applications.

False representations and intent

A communication is considered “false” or “fraudulent” if it’s about a material fact that you know isn’t true. It can also be considered “false” or “fraudulent” if you recklessly make the statement without caring whether it’s true or not and you made it with intent to defraud. The communication doesn’t have to be completely false as long as it is made with the intent to defraud. It can be a half-truth or just have the effect of concealing a material fact.

To prove mail or wire fraud involving money or property, prosecutors must show that you knowingly participated in a scheme to obtain someone’s money or property through material deception, with intent to defraud. An honest mistake does not establish that intent.

The government does not have to prove that the scheme succeeded or that you intended to cause a net financial loss. In Kousisis v. United States, the Supreme Court held that obtaining money through materially false pretenses can support a fraud conviction even when the victim receives goods or services worth the amount paid. Receiving full value therefore does not, by itself, defeat a fraud charge.

Materiality

The alleged deception must concern a material fact: one capable of influencing the decision at issue. Materiality is a separate element the government must prove. Whether a statement meets that requirement depends on the transaction and the role the statement played.

Mailing or wire transmission

The government must connect the mailing or transmission to the alleged scheme. For wire fraud, identify the charged interstate or foreign communication. For mail fraud, identify the mailing or carrier and its alleged purpose. The person charged need not have personally sent every communication.

Possible Penalties for Mail or Wire Fraud

Mail fraud and wire fraud generally carry up to 20 years in federal prison per count. The maximum increases to 30 years when the offense affects a financial institution or occurs in relation to a presidentially declared major disaster or emergency, including fraud involving benefits connected with that declaration. Those enhanced offenses also carry a statutory fine of up to $1 million.

A conviction can also result in:

  • Supervised Release after a prison sentence
  • Fines generally up to $250,000 for an individual or $500,000 for an organization, with a $1 million statutory maximum for qualifying financial-institution or disaster-related offenses. A higher fine may apply under the alternative gain-or-loss rule in 18 U.S.C. § 3571.
  • Restitution
  • Forfeiture

When a mail or wire fraud scheme involves misuse of another person’s identifying information, prosecutors may also bring aggravated identity theft charges. A conviction under 18 U.S.C. §1028A(a)(1) adds a mandatory two-year prison term consecutive to the sentence for the underlying fraud.

A criminal defense attorney from our law firm can analyze the specific facts of your case to determine the possible punishment you face if you are convicted.

How We Test the Allegation

Over the past two decades, David Edelstein has defended clients charged with federal mail fraud and wire fraud. He has been admitted to practice in the Southern District of Florida since 1996.

When a charge turns on an email, we read the whole exchange. What did the sender know when the email went out? Did an attachment disclose the very condition the government says was hidden?

If charges have been filed, we review the indictment count by count. That helps us identify issues for motions or trial and gives you a basis for weighing any plea proposal. Our guide to federal criminal cases explains what comes next after an indictment.

Discuss the Investigation or Charge

Tell us whether you received a subpoena, target letter, interview request, or indictment. Have the document, the next deadline, and a brief description of your role available. Ask how to provide confidential records before sending them.

CALL US NOW for a CONFIDENTIAL CONSULTATION at (305) 538-4545, or simply take a moment to fill out our confidential and secure intake form.* The additional details you provide will greatly assist us in responding to your inquiry.

*Due to the large number of people who contact us requesting legal representation, it is strongly suggested that you take the time to provide us with specific details regarding your case by filling out our confidential and secure intake form. The additional details you provide will greatly assist us in responding to your inquiry in a timely and appropriate manner.

IF YOU ARE MAKING A DECISION TO HIRE A MIAMI MAIL FRAUD ATTORNEY IN MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, MAKE SURE THAT YOU HIRE AN EXPERIENCED ATTORNEY WITH THE PROPER QUALIFICATIONS TO DEFEND YOU PROPERLY.