Reimagining Pretrial Justice in Miami – Why Our City Should Lead on Bail Reform
Update — October 2026: This article’s discussion of the dispute over Miami-Dade’s proposed bail reforms concerns events in 2023. Since January 2024, Florida law has required a statewide bond schedule for eligible defendants released before first appearance. Lower local schedules require Florida Supreme Court approval, although the statewide schedule does not bind a judge making an individual bail decision. Local reforms must also comply with Florida’s pretrial release and detention requirements.
America’s cash bail system is broken, unjustly criminalizing poverty and destroying lives. As a criminal defense lawyer in Miami for many years, I’ve witnessed this tragedy firsthand. Now, our chance to lead bold local reforms is being thwarted by politics.
Miami-Dade’s leaders developed plans to reduce reliance on cash bail by assessing defendant risk instead of ability to pay. This data-driven approach aimed to enhance public safety and equity in pretrial decisions. Roll out was slated for this year.
But Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis actively opposes such reforms, vowing to block liberal judges pursuing change. Hours after he proposed tougher statewide bail laws in Miami, our local courts paused implementation, wary of provoking a conflict.
This political resistance prevents progress and leaves our unjust system entrenched. Still, models for change exist that balance reform and public concerns. With perseverance and courage, Miami can pioneer improvements to uphold rights, safety and dignity for all.
The Moral Failure of Cash Bail
The Bureau of Justice Statistics reported that 450,700 people held in local jails at midyear 2024 were unconvicted. That figure includes people awaiting court action and people held for other reasons; it does not establish that all were jailed because they could not afford bail. The concern remains: a person’s lack of money should not, by itself, determine whether that person stays in jail before trial.
Cash bail can make freedom turn on wealth. When a court sets a monetary bond, one defendant may pay it easily while another remains jailed because the same amount is out of reach. Wealth does not guarantee release; Florida law permits, and sometimes requires, detention without bond. For defendants eligible for release, a lawyer can ask the court to consider a bond reduction or other appropriate release conditions.
Detained defendants also face much longer sentences, as incarceration hinders building a defense. Jail spreads COVID, causes depression, and increases suicide risk. Those risks are even more serious when local and national jail systems are already struggling with chronic understaffing and mismanagement. Can such an unjust system truly be called justice? We must challenge business-as-usual and demand better.
Embracing the Call to Action
The political will for reform is growing. Some states curtail cash bail with promising results. Many expand pretrial supervision to reduce detention. Activists demand change.
Miami had a rare chance to lead by addressing bail’s inequities head-on. Our community cares deeply about redemption and equality. We have a responsibility to redeem our outsized role in enabling injustice.
I commend Miami’s leaders for attempting data-driven reforms to base pretrial release more on risk versus ability to pay. Keeping our most vulnerable citizens out of jail aids rehabilitation and public safety. With proper implementation, we can end wealth-based detention without endangering communities.
But the governor’s vocal opposition gives local leaders cold feet. Fears of appearing soft on crime remain strong. Now Miami’s progress is stalled by divisive state politics instead of driving inclusive policy progress. We must persist in educating the public despite demagoguery.
For someone facing charges, these policy choices become concrete at the first appearance and bond hearing, where the court addresses eligibility for release and any conditions that may apply.
New York’s Promising Model
New York City offers a model worth studying. Its Mayor’s Office of Criminal Justice reported that judges ordered supervised release in more than 22,000 cases during fiscal year 2023. The program allows people to await trial in their communities with supervision and access to supportive services.
Miami should assess what it can learn from that approach. Any comparison should use clearly defined measures: court attendance and new arrests, with the reporting period stated. A monthly rearrest rate does not show the share of participants rearrested over the full life of their cases.
Miami should follow New York’s lead when politics allow. We too can shrink overreliance on cash bail through comprehensive, accountable reforms. But we must stand firm amidst resistance and fearmongering. Though difficult, progress is possible if we stay focused on justice.
Next Steps to a Just Future
Miami-Dade already operates a pretrial services program that supervises eligible defendants released by court order. Reform should build on that program, strengthen access to needed services, and measure how well it helps people return to court without new arrests. Judges and prosecutors should support release when lawful conditions can address the risks in the case.
And supervised release cannot function properly without adequately funded service providers, case managers, and social programs. This comprehensive approach will be complex but is utterly feasible if we make justice our priority.
Reforms will inevitably meet resistance from those wedded to current norms. We must stand firm against inevitable fearmongering and avoid steps backward. Progress requires perseverance, but the righteous path is rarely easy.
To achieve real change, all who believe in justice must speak up and demand reform. Contact officials at every level. Write op-eds calling for bold action. Use your vote to support pro-reform candidates. With community spirit and courage, Miami can turn the page on our broken bail system.
A More Just Miami is Possible
Miami has the tools to catalyze national pretrial justice reforms. We can break unjust cycles destroying lives and degrading human dignity. Now we must summon the perseverance and courage to implement solutions despite political obstruction.
With a spirit of justice and compassion, Miami can still be a beacon of progress that spurs reform nationwide. Though setbacks will arise, we cannot defer the dream. There are too many lives at stake. The time for action is upon us.
