The Fourth Amendment Is Not for Sale Act

Can the government buy sensitive personal data that it would otherwise need legal process to obtain? That question drove the Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act introduced in 2023. Dell Cameron’s July 2023 reporting for Wired examined the proposal and the privacy concerns behind it.

The Crux of the Matter

The Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable searches and seizures. Many searches require a warrant supported by probable cause, but exceptions apply. In Carpenter v. United States, the Supreme Court held that police generally need a warrant to obtain historical cell-site location records of the kind at issue in that case. The decision did not settle every question about government access to digital data, including purchases from data brokers.

If police obtain digital evidence in violation of your Fourth Amendment rights, a defense lawyer can assess whether a motion to suppress could keep that evidence out of your criminal case.

The Legislation and its Proponents

Representative Warren Davidson introduced H.R. 4639 in July 2023 with bipartisan support. The proposal sought to bar law enforcement and intelligence agencies from buying certain records from data brokers and to require specified legal process for covered disclosures. The required process would depend on the records sought; a subpoena, court order, and warrant are not interchangeable.

Significance of the Bill

Why is this so important to you? You may think that if you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear. But the Fourth Amendment isn’t about hiding; it’s about privacy, about the assurance that your personal affairs, your location, your private interactions, and more, are safe from unwarranted government intrusion.

Location records can also draw people into investigations when they have no connection to a crime. Our article on police use of geofence warrants explains how requests for records tied to a place and time can expose innocent people’s movements.

What’s Next?

The House passed H.R. 4639, the Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act, on April 17, 2024, by a vote of 219–199. House passage alone did not make the bill law. On March 5, 2026, lawmakers introduced the Protect Liberty and End Warrantless Surveillance Act of 2026, which includes a title called the Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act. These legislative efforts seek to limit government access to sensitive data sold by private companies.

Conclusion

The Fourth Amendment is a cornerstone of our democratic society, crucial in balancing the powers of the government and the rights of individuals. The Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act is an attempt to reaffirm that principle in the digital age. For us in Miami, and indeed for all Americans, it’s an essential piece of legislation that we should follow closely. We’ll continue to track its progress and share any important updates here. After all, understanding our rights is the first step towards protecting them.

As a criminal defense lawyer, I stand firmly by the Fourth Amendment rights. I believe in the principle that everyone deserves their personal privacy and security. If you or someone you know is facing a legal issue where privacy rights are being challenged, don’t hesitate to reach out.